+1 (877) 438-5566
info@fullonconsulting.com
>>Client Success>>

IT Program Audit: Benefits Administrator

Independent IT program audit of a multi-year benefits administration transformation

IT Program Audit: Catching Risks Early and Averting a $20M Loss

A national health benefits administrator was a quarter of the way through a self-funded, multi-year transformation expected to save $72 million. Leadership asked for an outside audit while there was still time to prevent problems instead of repairing them.

This IT program audit case study shows how Don Hook and a small team ran a four-week independent program assessment for a benefits administration company owned by a larger financial services firm. The audit looked across people, process and technology, rated every finding, and gave the sponsors a short list of actions to take before the first major release.

$20.9M

Program budget under review

4 weeks

From kickoff to final report

46

Findings rated by impact, priority and complexity

$20M

Estimated loss averted

Situation: A Self-Funded Transformation Under Pressure

The company was replacing its claims, portal, reporting and data warehouse systems with one integrated platform across multiple regional offices. The program was expected to save $72 million and pay for itself. About 25% of the $20.9 million budget had been spent, construction was under way with outside vendors, and the first release was months away.

The pressure was real: compliance deadlines, self-imposed dates, savings that depended on staffing changes, and regional offices worried about how customers would react to a new platform.

Challenge: Find the Risks Before They Become Problems

The CIO and COO wanted an outside, independent view of whether the program was set up to succeed. They needed it fast, without slowing the program down, and with recommendations specific enough to act on.

Action: A Four-Week, Six-Dimension Audit

The team interviewed 37 people, from the program sponsors and regional presidents to project leads, IT operations and internal audit, and reviewed plans, budgets, status reports and architecture. Findings were organized into six dimensions:

Strategic alignmentExecutive sponsorship, alignment with other projects, and whether the cost/benefit case still held up
Portfolio and project managementScope, schedule, risk, issue, resource and cost management, and the PMO
Business and functional alignmentProcess ownership, requirements, business participation and regulatory requirements
TechnologyArchitecture, integration, legacy conversions and migration plans
Solution delivery and supportMethodology, testing, training, rollback plans and vendor delivery
Organizational readinessChange management, future-state processes, training and benefits tracking

Each of the 46 findings was rated for impact (high, medium or low), priority (address within 30, 90 or 180 days) and complexity (as a share of program budget). The audit also called out what was working, so it wasn't lost in the changes.

What was working:

  • Strong executive sponsorship and a shared vision across business and IT.
  • A sound architecture built on standard, reliable technology.
  • A change management plan and a named change lead already in place.
  • Vendor agreements negotiated well, especially on rates.

What needed attention:

  • No master schedule tying the sub-projects together, so the critical path wasn't known.
  • Costs weren't tracked against estimates, and the cost/benefit case hadn't been updated.
  • Risks and issues appeared in status reports but weren't actively managed.
  • Key people were working overtime with no backups, and critical knowledge sat with a few individuals.
  • No rollback or contingency plans, and one vendor was likely to miss its next delivery date.
  • Customer communications and market readiness were behind the release schedule.

Result: Eight Priority Actions and a $20M Loss Averted

The audit concluded that the program was in relatively good standing for its size and stage, with clear gaps in how it was being run. Most findings were about preventing problems, not recovering from them. The sponsors received eight priority actions:

  1. Add an experienced program manager to support the existing leadership.
  2. Rebuild the plans with dependencies, the critical path, named resources and a consolidated risk plan.
  3. Refresh project management skills, and reassess performance in 30 to 60 days.
  4. Finish market readiness planning and fold it into the program plan and budget.
  5. Add program controller support for cost and resource tracking.
  6. Review the regional rollout plans and dates with business and operations leaders.
  7. Rebuild the cost/benefit case from bottom-up estimates.
  8. Set up governance with budget, schedule, scope and benefit reviews at each major milestone.

The report also recommended short follow-up audits before each major milestone, to check progress on the recommendations while there was still time to act.

Don walked the COO through the results in person. Acting on them, the company decided not to start another major project with the same team, averting an estimated $20 million loss. The audit was judged a success by the sponsors.

Why an Independent Audit Works

The people closest to a program have the most invested in how it is going, and leadership usually sees it through status reports written by the team. An outside auditor with no stake in the current plan, and enough technical depth to test what people say against the plans, budgets and architecture, gives sponsors an honest picture they can act on.

The return comes from the decisions the audit informs, and those are almost always larger than the audit itself. Here, four weeks of review shaped a decision worth an estimated $20 million.

Why it matters: The best time to audit a program is a quarter of the way in, when the plans are real but most of the money hasn't been spent.

This engagement was led by Don Hook as a Vice President at The Revere Group, before he founded Full On Consulting. Client details are withheld.

Let's Get Started

Running a big program and want an independent read before the next milestone? Let's talk.

An Independent Read, While There's Time to Act

Full On Consulting runs independent IT and program assessments led by a former CIO: rated findings, priority actions and a plan your leadership can act on.

WHY FULL ON CONSULTING

Senior Consultants, No Junior Bench

Every engagement is led by Don and delivered by senior specialists he has worked with before, including the partners who configure, develop and handle security. Named consultants and bios in every proposal. The people who sell the work do the work.

$40M+ in Documented Savings

Our track record includes $40M+ in verified client savings, a $130M M&A integration across 90+ global facilities, and an end-user computing transformation for 18,000 employees. We deliver measurable outcomes — not just recommendations.

25+ Years of Enterprise Experience

Our consultants average 25+ years of enterprise IT experience across Fortune 500 and mid-market companies. We have run the same programs we are being asked to lead — across SAP, Oracle, Salesforce, ServiceNow, and large-scale transformations.

Strategy Through Execution

We do not hand you a strategy deck and walk away. Our teams stay engaged from initial assessment through go-live — accountable for outcomes, not just deliverables. If we recommend it, we are prepared to execute it.

Boutique Agility

As a boutique firm, we move faster, adapt to your priorities, and work with your team rather than around it. No bureaucracy, no layers of overhead — just focused, senior-led execution from day one.

A Partner, Not a Vendor

We build long-term relationships grounded in trust and integrity. Many of our clients have engaged us across multiple initiatives and refer us to peers — because we do what we say we will do, every time.

Copyright © 2026 Full On Consulting
info@fullonconsulting.com
Privacy Policy
 
Free CIO Assessment Tool
Schedule a Free Consultation